
Last year, Maureen Johnson’s The Last Little Blue Envelope was nearing publication and the book before it, 13 Little Blue Envelopes, was offered for free on Kindle. Not wanting to pass up free books, I downloaded 13 to my iPod and read it over a series of lunches. Each meal was like a brief escape to Europe with plucky teen Virginia (Ginny) as she matured and found herself over the course of her dead aunt’s instructional letters.
When I met Maureen Johnson at ALA 2011 during the YA Author Coffee Klatch, I exposed her to my dorkiness. Our short exchange went something like this:
“Hi, I’m Maureen Johnson!”
“Hey, I really liked 13 Little Blue Envelopes. That was really slick how it was free on Kindle just before the next book came out.”
“Yes, it was a promotion. That was the point.”
“Right. I’m just saying… it was a good idea.”
Then Johnson got to the business of promoting her next bestseller and I shut up for the rest of time.
At the beginning of this month, YALSA announced its Best of the Best reading challenge, which I am now partway through. For my first book, I used The Last Little Blue Envelope because it has been staring at me ever since I read its predecessor and so that I could start the reading challenge with something familiar.
Well, what do you know. Both books are fun reads.
My enjoyment of Johnson’s writing stands out to me because of the librarian chatter over the boys cave one school library created in order to attract more boys. In the linked story, readership among boys has gone up – success! Except that measuring alienation is nearly impossible – worry! The concept of a “reading cave” that happens to be stocked with titles that often appeal to boys sounds fine, except this cave labels its books “It’s A Guy Thing.” Why bother with that kind of segregation? Just build a Reading Cave and invite boys more than usual if they are the target demographic. Maybe a “Girls Boutique” with pink carpet and frilly lace displays would attract some girls to the school library, but it would also reinforce stereotypes about girls and turn boys and girls away from the section. Attracting more girls would be seen as a success, but at what cost?
Maureen Johnson owned this issue a couple of years ago with her blog post Sell The Girls, and as one of her recent fans, I cannot agree more with her sentiments. As a male in his mid-20s, I did not immediately reject the prospect of a teenage girl protagonist. I’m also a YA author whose job it is to be familiar with that demographic amongst others, but still. The experience was fun and painless. The romance in Johnson’s books does not make me gag, because there are valuable perspectives and lessons about romance embedded in the story. (The romance of Twilight is another matter, which I believe exists for its own sake, but this is a post about not pre-judging people’s tastes so I’ll stop here.)
For example, one of of Ginny’s letters says to use some money from the aunt’s bank account to pay an artist for their work. Ginny finds a small theater with a one-man production and decides to do the (clever, desirable) artist, Keith, a favor by buying all of the seats. Keith is extremely flattered by the gesture, but is disappointed that Ginny is now his entire audience. Ginny tries to give away some tickets, but the curtain call is too soon and she just watches the show alone.
Do you think there might be a message there for boys and girls about the dangers of possessiveness in relationships? That in order for both people in a relationship to flourish, each must let the other interact with the world and not smother each other into a one-person show for an audience of one?
That’s just one example; there are many in both of the Blue Envelope books. And I have booktalked the books since reading them. In my limited experience, girls and boys can be talked into taking a look, but girls and boys split in opinion once they see the books’ covers, which is unfortunate. I tell teens not to judge books by their covers, but wow do book covers subtly judge their audiences. As a coworker once put it, we could suggest books a lot more easily if they were all monochromatic with the title on the spine.
As for me, “guy fi” fits my tastes as much as “chick lit” ever did. And I suspect that could be the case for you, too.